The Film TestLeica M9 · Leica MP · Kodak 160Hawaiʻi
Leica M9 vs Portra 160: can you tell which is film?
An 18-megapixel CCD and a roll of Kodak color film, the same island light, moments apart. Watch, then test your eyes.
Up close: the Portra 160 scan
Hover or touch to magnify
Kodak Portra 160, Waikiki, lab-scanned. Move over the photo (or press and drag on a phone) to look at the grain, skin and the ColorChecker up close. This frame is the one we measured to build the P160 presets.
Skin and sweater, magnified. Soft grain, warm but restrained skin.The ColorChecker, magnified. Its 24 patches are what we measured.
Watch the experiment
Before you read the verdict, see if your eyes can tell.
Leica M9 vs Kodak Portra 160: can you tell which is film? Open on YouTube
The eye test: drag the line, study the color
Two photographs, made moments apart. One with the Leica M9, the other with the Leica MP on Kodak color film. Look at skin, foliage, blue fabric and sand before you reveal the answer.
Image AImage B
Drag the handle, or tab to it and use the arrow keys. The exposures are closely matched but not perfectly registered, so compare color and rendering rather than alignment.
Can a CCD file feel like film?
After selling my Leica M11 and going back to the M9, I wanted to get past the mythology of “CCD color.” The useful question was not whether the M9 beats a modern camera. It was whether its color and texture could be mistaken for a film stock I know well.
I photographed closely related scenes with a Leica M9 and a Leica MP loaded with Kodak color film, moments apart but not with the same lens. So this is an observational comparison of finished pictures, not a lab test with identical optics. A ColorChecker gave both a common starting point: the film scan was white-balanced in Lightroom, then modest exposure, contrast and vibrance adjustments brought the two together, not to crown a winner, but to see where their visual languages overlap.
A second look · Mokapu Beach
Different frames, a similar conversation: white fabric, warm sand, tropical greens, skin and reflected ocean light.
Natural and surprisingly film-like after modest balancing
Gentle, familiar color; the first scan read warmer
Reds & blues
More saturated: vivid reds, ocean blues, blue-greens
More restrained, softer separation
Sky & teal
Sky leaned purple-magenta; teal shifted bluer
A quieter palette
Texture
CCD noise looked surprisingly organic
Grain stays distinctive, yet the two feel close
Once balanced, several pairs were genuinely hard to call without careful inspection. Stronger saturation is the clearest M9 tell.
The M9 is not Portra 160. But after modest corrections, the family resemblance is much stronger than I expected.Laurence Balter · field conclusion
It does not prove Kodak engineered the M9’s sensor to imitate film. The lenses differed, and a film scan is already an interpretation: exposure, chemistry, scanner, white balance and Lightroom all shape what reaches your screen.
From the test to a preset: the P160
The Waikiki frame at the top of this page is where the P160 came from. Claude and I measured the ColorChecker in five Portra 160 frames, normalized their exposure on the middle gray, and fitted a tone curve from the six neutral patches and color shifts from the other eighteen. Then I pulled back anything that looked heavy-handed in real scenes, so skies stay pale and the ocean keeps its color. On the chart the grays land within about 0.6 ΔE of the film; the colors average 4.6, by choice, because a preset has to look right on your photographs, not just on 24 squares.
The result works on any camera’s raw files, and on iPhone: soft highlights, warm skin, pale skies, the Portra feel without the scan.
Questions
Does the Leica M9 really look like Kodak color film? After modest white-balance and tonal adjustments, the two were surprisingly hard to tell apart at first glance. The M9 stayed more saturated, especially in reds, blues and blue-greens.
Were the same lenses used? No. The photographs were made moments apart with different lenses, so this compares finished images, not sensors in isolation.
Do I need a Leica to use the P160? No. It works on raw files from any camera in Lightroom, and the iPhone edition works in Lightroom mobile.
Want the M9’s color instead? The M9 CCD profile gives the Leica M11, Q3 and SL3 the color of the M9, measured the same way. For Kodachrome, see the K64 presets.